Why (Re)launching the EUI Social Movement Working Group?
Academic working groups are powerful scholarly tools where junior and senior students can present their empirical works, discuss theories and concepts, and exchange innovative ideas in a friendly and scientific stimulating environment. Their proliferation and recognition within academia help overcome the rigid disciplinary distinctions of sciences, facilitating a fruitful scientific cooperation among scholars from different ideological schools of thought. Working groups seem to be even more important today, in the so called knowledge society, to the extent that their proliferation can contribute to breaking down the ivory tower of academia, facilitating the socialization and dissemination of critical knowledge. Working group can, thus, be seen as the cornerstone of knowledge production in contemporary society. It is precisely with this spirit that we aim at (re)launching the EUI Social Movement Working Group for the academic year 2014/2015 by organizing a new seminar series on the theme of “the return of Marx” in contemporary sociology, and especially in social movement studies. Doing so, we think to resume at best the tradition of scientific cooperation, theoretical challenges, and exchange of ideas characterizing the past editions of the Social Movement Working Group within the EUI academic community. Writing a PhD thesis is not a solipsistic intellectual effort produced by an individual mind, but rather needs to be constantly fuelled by the presence of a stimulating academic community. We think that the relaunch of the Social Movement Working Group represents a small yet indispensable step for the construction of that community.
… What are we going to talk about?
There is a widespread agreement among a certain number of movement scholars on the fact that the recent wave of protests has put into crisis the dominant theories of social movements. Some of their analytical and conceptual tools seem no longer to be effective in explaining the factors triggering mobilization. How to better understand the outburst of current mobilizations? How to explain their framing processes, repertoires of action, goals, and outcomes? We think that bringing back political economy in the study of social movements is a first and necessary step to be undertaken to answer these questions. This view is also shared by some of the most recent strands of social movement research, aiming at (re)taking seriously economist perspectives, and especially Marxist, in the study of contemporary mobilizations. By calling for a (re)turn to Marxist and other political economist perspectives in social movement research we would like to underline the importance of bringing “capitalism” back in—as Hetland and Goodwin (2013) have stressed in a recently published article—even in the analyses of the “new” and “apparently” post-materialist movements of the last three decades. Contemporary society and its structural and cultural changes need to be (re)investigated through new conceptual and analytical lens embodying more critical perspectives. The themes and approaches that we will present and debate over the ten planned sessions go precisely in this direction. In particular, we look at different interpretations of Marx which have today heavily influenced some strands of various disciplines, ranging from political economy to sociology and political theory, to discuss whether and to what extent they may offer useful insights to understand the current capitalist transformations. To this end, we will bring together and discuss with leading figures in the fields of social movement studies, political economy, economic sociology, and political theory. In the 2014/2015 academic year, the Social Movement Working Group aims to starting a debate on the possibility to create a common analytical language, drawing selectively from distinct epistemological approaches, capable of critically investigating the contemporary capitalist reality in all its facets. To do so, we need to challenge the established division of labor characterizing mainstream social sciences both in their epistemological and empirical respects. From an epistemological point of view, we aim to overcoming the disciplinary boundaries of social sciences by combining approaches and concepts of various disciplines in order to build up a shared theoretical framework through which to critically analyze society. From an empirical point of view, we aim to overcoming the established thematic boundaries of social sciences that have prevented scholars from having a broader comprehension of capitalist society and its transformations by merging and bringing together topics and objects of study that are usually confined in (over)specialized scientific fields. As key example of this disciplinary overspecialization, one can think of the neat distinction made by the American sociology between social movement and labor studies. The former are strictly focused on the study of “new” social movements, whereas the latter investigate unions and labor organizations(are we sure that such a sharp epistemological division of social science reflects an ontological division of social reality?). The most important lesson that we can learn from Marx is precisely his ability to explore social reality through a holistic perspective, as it is only by building a broader framework of analysis that is possible to fully investigate capitalism and its changes. The underlying question that will accompany all the sessions and will conclude our seminar with the final roundtable is thus: can Marx get back in social movement studies?
How to join the working group?
Working group is open to all researchers and professors within EUI. If you wish to participate in this working group or receive information about forthcoming sessions just write an email to the organizers of the working group: Lorenzo Cini (firstname.lastname@example.org), Daniela Chironi (Daniela.email@example.com) and Eliska Drapalova (Eliska.firstname.lastname@example.org), Federico Tomasello (email@example.com).
The working group will meet approximately on monthly bases. In each session a professor or researcher will present his work that is fitting into the session thematic with one complementary reading in order to deepen the debate. Researchers act as discussants. After each session we will head together to have a pizza or aperitivo to follow our discussion in a more informal manner.
Session 1 (08/10/2014): Bringing Capitalism Back In. Social Movements in Times of Austerity, Seminar Room 2, Badia. Speaker: Prof. Donatella della Porta (Director of Cosmos, Robert Schuman Center for Advanced Studies and Scuola Normale Superiore) – Reading Material – Discussants: Federico Tomasello, Alice Mattoni
Session 2 – 28th October 2014 – Creditocracy and the Case for Debt Refusal, Seminar Room 4, Badia
Speaker: Prof. Andrew Ross (New York University) – Reading Material
Discussants: Eliska Drapalova, Jerome Roos
Session 3 – 12th November 2014 – Marxism and Social Movements: Towards a Productive Conversation, Seminar Room 2, Badia, 5 p.m. Speaker: Prof. Colin Barker (Metropolitan University of Manchester) – Reading Material. Discussants: Parthena Xanthopolou-Dimitriadou, Tommaso Giordani
Session 4 – 9th December 2014 – Yet another Gramscian Moment?!: Gramsci and the Crises of the 1920s, the 1980s and Now, Seminar Room 2, Badia, 5.30 p.m.
Speaker: Prof. Richard Bellamy (Director of Max Weber Programme EUI) – Reading Material
Discussants: Lorenzo Zamponi, Thuc Linh Nguyen Vu
Session 5 – 28th January 2015 – From the ‘Operaio Sociale’ to the Multitude: A Marxist Approach to Social Movements Theory?
Speaker: Prof. Antonio Negri (independent) – Reading Material
Discussants: Daniela Chironi, Helge Hiram Jensen
Session 6 – 8th April 2015 – Theory and Practice of the Unionisation of the Self Employed in Europe and in the U.S. – 5pm – Badia Fiesolana, Emeroteca.
Speaker: Prof. Sergio Bologna (independent) – Reading Material
Discussants: Jamie Woodcock, Priska Daphi
Session 7 – 29th April 2015 – From Social Struggles to Political Institutions? Processes of Institutionalization and Transformation of Social Movements between the Latin American and the European Experience – 5pm – Badia Fiesolana, Emeroteca.
Speaker: Prof. Sandro Mezzadra (Università di Bologna) – Reading Material
Discussants: Cesar Guzman-Goncha, Daniela Chironi
Session 8 – 22nd May 2015 – Taking Crisis Seriously: Capitalism on its Way Out
Location: Scuola Normale Superiore, Palazzo Strozzi, Firenze.
Speaker: Prof. Wolfang Streeck (Max Plank Institute) – Reading Material – Discussants:
Session 9 (03/06/2015): Marxist Political Economy and Social Movements: Bridging a Theoretical (and Political) Gap
Speaker: Prof. Emiliano Brancaccio (Università del Sannio) – Reading Material
Final Roundtable (June 2015): Why Marxism(s) Should Speak to Social Movement Studies and Vice Versa
Discussion with: Donatella della Porta, Alice Mattoni, Lorenzo Cini and Federico Tomasello
Moderators: Daniela Chironi